RSS Feeds
Info Zone
Discussion Forum
DISCUSSION FORUM
January's Hot Topic:
Artificial vs. Real Indoor Plants -
Should It Matter To A Gardener?
Let’s face it, when January rolls around in our northern environs, there’s not much gardening to be done, and thus there’s not much for a gardener to be doing. Sure, we can dream of spring and plan for the extravagant gardens and grandiose landscaping projects that are on our horizons. But planning is only so much fun in the confines of our feverish winter cabins, and it doesn’t get much dirt underneath our fingertips.
It’s also a challenge for us to keep plants in our midst in January. Our outdoor plants are buried beneath a few feet of snow or are deep in their midwinter slumber, not to be awakened for a few months to come. All we see is an endless ocean of white and gray throughout our landscapes, save for a few stalwart but bedraggled evergreens here and there. Oh, how we long for greenery, for flowers and foliage and colors and life!
For some gardeners, January is a month for some well-deserved rest from their passion. For others, this is the time for indoor gardening. Some long for the show and vibrancy enough to turn their attention to artificial plants, rich with colors and texture, to liven up their homes. But are artificial plants sacrilege for the true gardener? Can one profess to be a green thumb and yet create winter beauty indoors with prefabricated plants and flowers?
Here’s what a couple of veteran Northscapers have to say on this delicate matter;
I’m sorry, but in my opinion artificial plants are a copout. Their presence in a home tells me that a gardener does not live there! I don’t think you can call yourself an avid gardener, have a green thumb and enviable gardens for three whole seasons of the year, and then have plastic plants adorning your winter sanctuary. We gardeners work with real plants, and for us, there can be no substitutes made from polymerized petroleum or spun silk. Fake is fake, and real is real!
There are a number of ways for gardeners to stay actively gardening and working with living plants during the coldest winter months that will liven up a home without the need for silk flowers or plastic greenery. Grow a few live indoor plants or tropicals - many of them are virtually carefree. Experiment with paperwhites and narcissi in pots on the windowsill. Take up a hobby like orchids, bonsai or cacti. Snip off a couple of plum branches and bring them inside to force the fragrant flowers. Take some hardwood cuttings and propagate some new plants for spring.
There is simply no need to resort to fakery to keep a home looking vibrant in winter and to keep the gardener’s touch alive. Goodness knows, there are already enough manufactured constituents in our lives.
Indoor gardening is all right for those with a green thumb and an abundance of free time, but for those of us possessing the black thumb of demise, best prevented from touching plants requiring any form of maintenance, fake is the way to go! Sure, some people relax through the hobby and the act of gardening, and good for them. However others, like me, find enjoyment in the sight of greenery and the break from the hard lines of human construction. Who cares if a plant is real or fake, as long as it is green, leafy and low (ok, NO) maintenance and serves its intended purpose of creating an atmosphere of relaxation. Certainly not me.
Really, what is the difference? A fake plant is just some artist’s rendition of the “master work” generated by Mother Nature. Were I a fan of Van Gogh, I could equally appreciate his art from a print rather than an original, and at a fraction of the cost I may add. The same holds for greenery. What matters is the visual appeal and appearance of the natural elements to tame the indoors and provide a reasonable simulation of a natural environment in the dead of winter. I feel no need to dig in the dirt and spend time I don’t have watering and re-potting plants indoors, only to have to eventually discard them (since I will certainly have forgotten to water them).
I see no reason to discriminate against fake plants just because they were “nurtured and coddled” on a factory assembly line instead of someone’s greenhouse. That’s just “reality snobbery”. I guess some are just not a tolerant and understanding as I am. Snobs!
Post your replies to this thread and BE HEARD!
Just an observation in hindsight, the title of this month's debate, “Artificial vs. Real Indoor Plants - Should It Matter To A Gardener?” sort of says it all.