Plant Search Discussion Forum Contact Us Site Map
 
 Home
Info Zone
Tool Shed
Garden Cafe
Links
Business Solutions
About Northscaping

 RSS Feeds

Info Zone

Discussion Forum

DISCUSSION FORUM

A Message Board, Guestbook, or Poll hosted for your website.
 | New Posts
 
Forums > Gardener's Edge > Hot Topic - Artificial vs. Real Indoor Plants
 
 


Thread Tools  | Search This Thread 
Reply
 
Author Comment
 
Moderator
    Jan 01, 2008Reply with quote#1

January's Hot Topic:

 

Artificial vs. Real Indoor Plants - 

Should It Matter To A Gardener?

 

Let’s face it, when January rolls around in our northern environs, there’s not much gardening to be done, and thus there’s not much for a gardener to be doing. Sure, we can dream of spring and plan for the extravagant gardens and grandiose landscaping projects that are on our horizons. But planning is only so much fun in the confines of our feverish winter cabins, and it doesn’t get much dirt underneath our fingertips.

 

It’s also a challenge for us to keep plants in our midst in January. Our outdoor plants are buried beneath a few feet of snow or are deep in their midwinter slumber, not to be awakened for a few months to come. All we see is an endless ocean of white and gray throughout our landscapes, save for a few stalwart but bedraggled evergreens here and there. Oh, how we long for greenery, for flowers and foliage and colors and life!

 

For some gardeners, January is a month for some well-deserved rest from their passion. For others, this is the time for indoor gardening. Some long for the show and vibrancy enough to turn their attention to artificial plants, rich with colors and texture, to liven up their homes. But are artificial plants sacrilege for the true gardener? Can one profess to be a green thumb and yet create winter beauty indoors with prefabricated plants and flowers?

 

Here’s what a couple of veteran Northscapers have to say on this delicate matter;

 

Jim Says...

 

I’m sorry, but in my opinion artificial plants are a copout. Their presence in a home tells me that a gardener does not live there! I don’t think you can call yourself an avid gardener, have a green thumb and enviable gardens for three whole seasons of the year, and then have plastic plants adorning your winter sanctuary. We gardeners work with real plants, and for us, there can be no substitutes made from polymerized petroleum or spun silk. Fake is fake, and real is real!

 

There are a number of ways for gardeners to stay actively gardening and working with living plants during the coldest winter months that will liven up a home without the need for silk flowers or plastic greenery. Grow a few live indoor plants or tropicals - many of them are virtually carefree. Experiment with paperwhites and narcissi in pots on the windowsill. Take up a hobby like orchids, bonsai or cacti. Snip off a couple of plum branches and bring them inside to force the fragrant flowers. Take some hardwood cuttings and propagate some new plants for spring.

 

There is simply no need to resort to fakery to keep a home looking vibrant in winter and to keep the gardener’s touch alive. Goodness knows, there are already enough manufactured constituents in our lives.

 

Andy Says...

 

Indoor gardening is all right for those with a green thumb and an abundance of free time, but for those of us possessing the black thumb of demise, best prevented from touching plants requiring any form of maintenance, fake is the way to go! Sure, some people relax through the hobby and the act of gardening, and good for them. However others, like me, find enjoyment in the sight of greenery and the break from the hard lines of human construction. Who cares if a plant is real or fake, as long as it is green, leafy and low (ok, NO) maintenance and serves its intended purpose of creating an atmosphere of relaxation. Certainly not me.

 

Really, what is the difference? A fake plant is just some artist’s rendition of the “master work” generated by Mother Nature. Were I a fan of Van Gogh, I could equally appreciate his art from a print rather than an original, and at a fraction of the cost I may add. The same holds for greenery. What matters is the visual appeal and appearance of the natural elements to tame the indoors and provide a reasonable simulation of a natural environment in the dead of winter. I feel no need to dig in the dirt and spend time I don’t have watering and re-potting plants indoors, only to have to eventually discard them (since I will certainly have forgotten to water them).

 

I see no reason to discriminate against fake plants just because they were “nurtured and coddled” on a factory assembly line instead of someone’s greenhouse. That’s just “reality snobbery”. I guess some are just not a tolerant and understanding as I am. Snobs!

 

What Do YOU Say?

 

Post your replies to this thread and BE HEARD!

 

Guy
    Jan 02, 2008Reply with quote#2

Happy new year to all, including "fake" & "copout" gardeners!...

Plastic plants should be outlawed, along with plastic gnomes on front yards...
I know these issues can't (or shouldn't) be made illegal, that's why we're a tolerant society!

I have a neighbour who takes it to a higher (trailer park) level...
They have plastic OUTDOOR plants in hanging baskets!!
They're out YEAR ROUND....... Nice.
Talk about lowering property values...
Plastic plants would bring no enjoyment for me, since there is no satisfaction
in watching them NOT grow.....
Zero challenge... i like to grow plants that challenge me.
Also, plastic plants are worthless for removing indoor pollution. Maybe even worsen indoor pollution, lol...

I have about 10 or so indoor plants, most of them are not difficult to keep;
snake plants, spider plant, chinese evergreen, xmas cactus...
my 3 favorites are my dinner plate aralia,ming aralia & herringbone plant.
I'm still looking to purchase a japanese holly plant or cast iron plant,
2 other very low maintenance plants...

Like Jim said, petro plants are a copout for lazy gardeners.

Guy


Jim Kohut
    Jan 02, 2008Reply with quote#3



I know what you mean - I've never had a neighbor that put up artificial plants outdoors (I would probably move, trees and all!!), but I've seen people in a couple of major cities with yards full of artificial flowers. Words like tacky and cheap just don't cut it. I mean, a front planter full of "tulips" in full bloom in November? In vibrant shades of red paint, yellow paint and blue paint?

Easy, stomach...

Jim K.

Glen
    Jan 02, 2008Reply with quote#4

Let's not forget there are different qualities of artificial plants, but I agree that most of the discount store varieties look cheap and, well, artificial.  I don't know why people would put them outside, they often look a phony shade of green and they fade fast to an even more artificial-looking shade.

Do artificial plants have a place inside the home?  Perhaps, but in limited use.  Let's not forget that not every home, nor room in every home, has great light which allows real plants to flourish.  Plus, I see nothing wrong with the occasional vase of artificial "cut" flowers.  Would I fill my house with artificial plants, no, as I feel they have a certain 'cheap look' to them and can never replace the real thing (would rather have less plants than artificial ones).

I have two artificial plants, an artificial hanging basket in the dark corner in the bedroom and then an artificial banana plant in the basement.  Other than that, I have real plants ranging from a Canela (Cinnamon) tree in the living room that struggles yet hangs in there, to a hoya, a cactus, ivy, and some pink flamingo type flowering plant that has never bloomed.  The thing is, only the plants that get the prime real estate in the south living room window do okay.  Alot of my plants look unkept and struggling because I really don't have great lighting conditions.  In fact, I have an ivy in the bathroom that's 8 inches long after 3 years but still hangs in there.

A great portion of my window space, from the cool basement window to the bedroom and living room windows, are filled with overwintering 'annuals' from outdoors such as geraniums and a copper leaf shrub that has lost most of it's leaves.  Most of these plants don't look great either, but the intent is to keep them alive until they can once again flourish outside.  I have a banana plant, started from seed last spring, that is growing in a pot in the north kitchen window.  I find it kind of amusing that a few months ago it was on the other side of that window, outside on the sunny warm deck.

By the way, one plant I discovered last year Zamioculcas plant (ZZ Plant).  It has an interesting look and is very tolerant of low-light indoors.  In fact, they say not to give it any sun, though mine received morning sun on the deck last summer and did fine.  The only drawback is that it's poisonous so care must be taken as to it's location in the home.

Glen



akeimou
    Jan 03, 2008Reply with quote#5

NEITHER!!

- i have dogs.  they think real plants are much better than kibbles, while fake plants are cool chewy toys

- plants, fake or otherwise, add to the dusting chore big time.  and i've seen lots of people ignoring the accumulated dust, esp in restaurants, yuk!

my mom has indoor plants.  i like the variegated hoya, and the colocasia with huge leaves that have contrasting veining on top.  she has lots of dried plant material too which are neither alive nor artificial.

me, i'd prefer that gardening stayed outdoors, to keep experiencing the wonder and excitement every time i opened the door to go out, not unlike Lucy opening the wardrobe door to the magic land of Narnia... 

okay, really, i just hate dusting, is all.

--meg
(lazy gardener, too lazy even for fake plants)

Andy
    Jan 03, 2008Reply with quote#6

OK - who's up for a gnome hunting expedition? They're sneaky little buggers, the way they just stand there and mock you.... Oh wait, that was a different thread.....

Meg - FEED YOUR DOGS!!! Poor things are becoming fake vegetarians. Mind you, I have never been inclined to taste test my fake plants, so they may in fact be a new delicacy. I suspect they would taste a little like ... um ... perhaps ... dust? Yummy!

As for the dust - I agree with your dust hating point. We can take care of that after the gnomes. I will say that I think that a fake plant would fare much better in the dishwasher than the genuine article. I think my dishwasher warranty is about to become void....

Now if you will excuse me, I have to go and dig up all of Jim's plants and replace them with fakers! Might need a pick axe though. All those lovely shades of red, yellow and blue. Metallic, with glitter *L*. A 30 foot tall metallic blue Maple tree with bright yellow Acorns!!! (attack purists)

(Sarcasm, just one of the many services I offer. OK, the only one.) 

- Andy -



Lorne
    Jan 04, 2008Reply with quote#7

Quote:
Originally Posted by Guy
Plastic plants should be outlawed, along with plastic gnomes on front yards... I know these issues can't (or shouldn't) be made illegal, that's why we're a tolerant society!


Shouldn't the gnomes have a nice $39.00 Canada Tire plastic ficus to ward off the summer sun?

I've had many indoor plants over the years but all that have survived are a Ponytail Palm (30 yrs old and stunted at 3 ft. from sparse water but still a handsome plant) and a 12 yr old Spider plant. I really don't like plastic plants but do have a plastic ficus, mentioned above, that a friend gave me . Many times I have meant to toss it in the trash but can't bring myself to do it. I think I will experiment, put it out on the back deck beside a window mounted bird feeder and see if it attracts more winter birds. Yes, I'm serious.

I did buy another small Ponytail Palm a few months back and it could use a bigger pot. Is this a bad time of year to re-pot indoor plants?
Glen
    Jan 19, 2008Reply with quote#8

Just an observation in hindsight, the title of this month's debate, “Artificial vs. Real Indoor Plants - Should It Matter To A Gardener?” sort of says it all.

I don't think artificial plants can really be considered gardening.  I think gardening is the art of caring for plants, nurturing, transplanting, trimming, watering, etc.  Maybe artificial plants fall into the category of floristry or just home decor?


Wow, a 30-year old ponytail palm sounds quite impressive.  I had one survive two years once and then made the fatal mistake of  too much water for too long a period.

Glen
akeimou
    Jan 21, 2008Reply with quote#9

i'd recommend looking into the Garden Gnome Liberation Front (freethegnomes.com).  they have lots of resources and info to help in this cause, even a database (gnomeswithouthomes.com) to contribute to.  oh, what an idea!  how about a fakeplant hunting expedition too?  and freethefakeplants.com, and dustyfakeplantswithouthomes.com...

i've actually tasted kibbles (human grade) by accident (it is a staple food in the house, next to dog hair).  surprisingly, it tastes a lot like my fake (veggie) burgers.  but i shall not take food from my babies, well, maybe if there's a ketchup-flavored one... (for some reason i have this notion that real ketchup on kibbles will be uber gross)

not to worry.  notice how quickly technology is advancing and integrating these days.  for example, one can now surf, take pictures, record movies, perform database queries on a cell phone.  soon we'll be able to wash plastic ivy with it too!  kidding aside, i bet that before you know it they'll come up with dishwashers that are fakeplant-safe.  but until then try improvising with a collander for now, that should prevent little fake leaf buds, flower parts, fruits and seeds from clogging the dishwasher.

okay, Andy, i just rented bobcats, tree spades, and U-hauls.  and just let me know when you'd like to dig Jim's plants and i'm gonna adopt them.  we gotta recycle!

well, it looks like the arguments in favor of fake plants for indoors are mounting.  for one, they're much easier to recycle--don't need to move earth like you do for real plants.  it will be easy enough to set up adoption communities for them, and web-supported ones at that.  they last much longer, no need to refrigerate or create special climates and lighting for them.  they don't need as much effort to maintain, talk about plant it and leave it!  they can be washed and refreshed (dust was not really a problem after all), can be handed down and enjoyed through many generations.  and they can even be more beautiful and of better quality than the real ones (esp when compared to indoor plants that don't get TLC).  fake plants are very practical for all intents and purposes.

i was at the airport the other day admiring the clump of young aspen trees in the atrium.  i was feeling sorry for these trees, probably not a lot of soil down there for the roots.  also noticed that the pruning was not done well, with stubs sticking out at least an inch from the main trunk.  still, they looked like happy enough trees.  thought i'd inspect closer... what the!  they were fake.  i thought, well, that answers that. :-]

--meg


Ryan H
    Jan 21, 2008Reply with quote#10

I would have to agree with a lot of you, that using artificial plants is not gardening at all. I also tend to like real over artificial.  Artificial flowers and plants should definitely not be used outdoors.  Its super tacky.  Indoors I think it falls under interior decorating or floral design and there are many applications where I think artificial is totally fine.  There is some overlap, because as gardeners, most of us like to "make pretty" what ever we do, and we like to bring the garden indoors, so using similar elements in decorating makes sense.  I still prefer real plants and would never buy a fake houseplant, but I found myself today looking at dried grass, twigs, and artificial foliage and flowers for a floral arrangement for the entryway where there isn't enough light to ever grow a plant.  There is some really nice artificial stuff that doesn't look plasticy at all.  But as a rule, real is always better than fake. 
anne
    Feb 21, 2010Reply with quote#11

for me i like too much real plants because its giving me energy life and hope and relaxing i dont like fake plants theres no life.
beth
    March 16, 2010Reply with quote#12

hello,

i know i am a little late on this discussion but in case anyone follows up.  i am not in favour of fake plants in my home BUT... i am glad we have some in our church sanctuary.  it is way too dark for live plants and the fake ficus offer some green visuals as well as breaking up all the manmade things at the front.  sometimes we have fake floral displays as well on the altar when there are no real ones to be had.  i know they are fake but i still appreciate the color and texture they bring to an otherwise boring beige rectangle room.

there's my 2 cents.

beth

ps my neighbor has some lovely blue and purple delphinums under her apple tree that "bloom" right from the snow melt until they are covered again.
Previous Thread | Next Thread
Page 1 of 2   1  |  2 > 
Reply

  Bookmarks  
Digg Diggdel.icio.us del.icio.usStumbleUpon StumbleUponGoogle Google